The hidden risk in decision-making: how to prevent information cascades in meetings

Have you ever been in a meeting where one person shares an opinion, and suddenly, everyone seems to align with it? The discussion shifts, alternative perspectives fade, and before you know it, the entire group agrees, without truly exploring other possibilities. This is the information cascade effect, and it can silently undermine the quality of decisions.

What is an information cascade?

An information cascade occurs when individuals, rather than relying on their own knowledge or judgment, follow the opinions of those who speak before them. The assumption is that earlier speakers have better insights, and as more people conform, alternative viewpoints get suppressed. Over time, a single idea, right or wrong, can dominate simply because it was expressed first.

This phenomenon has been studied extensively in behavioral economics and network theory. Easley & Kleinberg (2010) explain how cascades occur in real-life situations, such as people choosing crowded restaurants over empty ones, not because they have better information, but because they assume others made an informed choice.

The same happens in business settings: once a few influential voices support an idea, others may follow, fearing that dissenting could make them seem uninformed or out of sync with the group.

Why information cascades are dangerous in meetings

When an information cascade takes over, critical thinking is replaced by conformity. People stop questioning, diverse viewpoints disappear, and teams risk making suboptimal or even harmful decisions based on incomplete or biased reasoning. The impact can be enormous:

• Missed opportunities – Good ideas are never voiced because people assume the decision has already been made.

• False confidence – A decision may feel validated simply because many people agree, even if it lacks strong reasoning.

• Resistance to new data – Once a cascade begins, it's hard to introduce new evidence that contradicts the dominant view.

  
  

How to prevent information cascades in meetings

• Encourage independent thinking first Before opening a discussion, ask team members to write down their thoughts or vote anonymously. This ensures people express their own perspectives without being influenced by others.

• Vary who speaks first If the same people always start the discussion, their opinions carry disproportionate weight. Rotate who shares first, or start with insights from junior members before senior voices weigh in.

• Use silent brainstorming A technique called "silent meetings" allows team members to generate ideas in writing before discussion begins. This minimizes social influence and lets every idea be considered equally.

• Assign a “Red Team” Designate someone to challenge assumptions and question the dominant narrative. Their role is to introduce counterarguments, preventing premature consensus.

• Pause before converging on a decision Instead of rushing to agreement, introduce structured pauses. Ask: Are we overlooking anything? What would make us reconsider? Who disagrees and why?

• Seek external perspectives If an idea gains momentum too quickly, consult outside experts or stakeholders. External input can break internal cascades and introduce fresh perspectives.

The best teams don’t just agree quickly; they challenge each other before aligning. By actively countering information cascades, we can create space for better decisions, more innovative thinking, and a culture where people feel empowered to speak up.

________

Have you experienced meetings dominated by quick consensus, where alternative ideas fade away unnoticed? Information cascades can silently undermine decision-making quality, hindering career growth and limiting team innovation. Through personalized business coaching, talent coaching, and group coaching, Nicola Arnese helps individuals and teams overcome these hidden barriers, fostering independent thinking and meaningful dialogue. Interested in exploring how coaching can transform your professional journey and empower your team? Schedule your free, non-binding introductory session with Nicola Arnese today. Together, we’ll clarify your goals, uncover opportunities, and ensure your decisions reflect your true potential.